Future of Devon Libraries still in doubt as scrutiny calls for delay


Devon County Council’s proposed library overhaul is facing mounting criticism after scrutiny councillors called for a delay, warning key decisions may be made before full proposals are properly examined
A plea to delay a decision on how Devon’s libraries should be overhauled has been made after criticism of a report ahead of a crunch decision.
The outcome of a major consultation that secured more than 25,000 responses about the future of Devon’s libraries is being pored over by officials in a bid to create a range of proposals for potential changes to how the county’s libraries operate.
But a key scrutiny committee criticised a report put before it because analysis of the feedback remains ongoing, meaning it was not presented with any concrete proposals to scrutinise.
“This is thin gruel, but it’s all we have to eat,” said Councillor Simon Rake, vice-chair of the corporate infrastructure and regulatory services scrutiny committee.
Others echoed the frustration that the committee had not been presented with actual proposals to question, but cabinet members were among those to suggest that any changes could be positive, and reiterated that the council had found extra cash to help fund libraries.
That included a decision to reverse a proposed £650,000 savings target that had been pencilled in for the 2025/26 financial year, plus the creation of a £1 million transformation fund.
Possible developments within the potential overhaul of libraries include so-called ‘Open+’ technology, whereby library members would be able to use a library outside normal hours, while another suggestion was to group libraries into networks, meaning that even if a local library was closed, one nearby would be open.
But campaigners stressed the challenges of travelling between towns and villages by public transport, and suggested some of the most vulnerable library users would not be able to travel elsewhere to access services.
While the cabinet member overseeing the potential changes, Councillor Cheryl Cottle-Hunkin, and the council’s chief executive, Donna Manson, stressed positives about the council’s library services, the scrutiny committee repeated its frustration.
“I’m concerned and annoyed that we have not got the details of what will be proposed at cabinet, as there has been so much worry about the consultation, and I feel there is a lack of detail at such a very close stage to a decision being made in May,” said Councillor Sara Wilson (Green Party, Ilfracombe).
“It’s not helpful to us as councillors in our communities, as we should be able to answer questions about what’s developing.”
The report presented to the scrutiny committee contained high-level findings from the library consultation, including that 6,000 people said they would be willing to volunteer to help staff libraries, that more than half said proposed changes to library hours would affect how often they visit, and that nearly three-quarters (70 per cent) want extended opening hours.
But firm proposals that the council’s cabinet will debate and decide upon were lacking, and may now be created and voted on before the next scrutiny meeting.
Various members expressed displeasure at this, but cabinet member Councillor Dan Thomas (Liberal Democrat, South Brent & Yealmpton), who attended the meeting, stressed that almost half the cabinet were present and “here to hear what the committee wants”.
“We will then go to the cabinet and make a decision, and I think it’s disappointing that you think the cabinet won’t listen to one of its scrutiny committees,” he said.
He stated that during the budget-setting process at the recent full council meeting, around 80 per cent of the 24 amendment proposals were adopted, which he suggested showed the decision-making body did listen.
“We’re not against scrutiny,” he added. “I’m not a member of this committee, but I am here to listen, and if you make recommendations they will be heavily in my mind at cabinet.”
Cllr Rake noted that the lack of detail “cuts both ways”.
“As we are thin on detail, it allows the committee to make recommendations from a blank page,” he added.
The committee agreed seven recommendations to cabinet, including a request for cabinet to defer its decision to allow “pre-decision scrutiny”, and that any changes should not lead to a reduction in statutory operating hours.
Councillor Cheryl Cottle-Hunkin (Liberal Democrat, Torrington Rural) said it was important to stress that “no decisions have been made”.
“We are listening and there are a lot of positive opportunities arising out of the consultation,” Cllr Cottle-Hunkin stated.
“Without the consultation, we wouldn’t have got the information we do, or the potential support from residents, so I hope we can work together to make our libraries even stronger.”
Devon’s next cabinet meeting is on Wednesday 20 May, and it could be where a decision on the future of the library service is taken.
However, cabinet decisions can be ‘called in’, meaning a scrutiny committee could request the chance to question them before they become official policy.