Police Commissioner backs Chief Constable after Devon and Cornwall force downgraded

placeholder image
Devon & Cornwall Police

Devon and Cornwall’s Police and Crime Commissioner has backed Chief Constable James Vaughan to lead improvements within the force after inspectors raised serious concerns about leadership, investigations and the safeguarding of vulnerable victims

The force has been moved from Level Two to Level Three under the new policing performance system following an inspection by His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire & Rescue Services (HMICFRS).

Level Three provides targeted support and intervention and requires chief constables to develop improvement plans. Level Four is the system's highest level and is designated as special measures.

HMICFRS issued an accelerated cause of concern after finding that Devon and Cornwall Police was not effectively investigating crime or safeguarding victims.

Inspectors said failures in strategic leadership were affecting the force's ability to manage demand, investigate offences and protect vulnerable people. They also found that some investigations and safeguarding concerns had remained unallocated for extended periods, in some cases for several weeks.

The latest findings follow an HMICFRS revisit in August, after the force had been placed at Level Two in July. At that stage, inspectors had identified concerns about the standard of investigations and the safeguarding of adults and children at risk of harm.

HMICFRS said the force must take immediate action and will receive additional support while its progress is monitored.

Police and Crime Commissioner Alison Hernandez said the concerns reflected issues she had already been raising through her scrutiny of the force.

She pointed to a scrutiny report published by her office in July which included recommendations around improving the force's understanding of how quickly it was responding to reports involving vulnerable people at risk.

Commissioner Hernandez said: “These issues, while clearly concerning, come as no surprise and in fact reflect those I have been raising through my ongoing scrutiny for some time. As recently as July, a scrutiny report by my office made recommendations which included improving the force’s understanding of how quickly it is responding to reports involving vulnerable people at risk.

“The Inspectorate’s announcement raises further serious questions about the ability of the force’s strategic leadership to address these concerns. Therefore, the escalation to Level Three is a positive intervention that will give Chief Constable James Vaughan the support and resources he will need to lead further improvements to the service being provided to the public.

“I continue to have confidence that Mr Vaughan has the skills, experience and values to make the required change. I welcome the Chief Constable's offer to support him with additional, enhanced scrutiny which goes above and beyond my legal powers.

“In my 10 years as a Police and Crime Commissioner, it has been a constant source of frustration that me and my fellow representatives do not automatically have the right to be as intrusive as I believe is necessary.”

The latest inspection adds to a period of scrutiny of Devon and Cornwall Police's performance.

Earlier this year, HMICFRS's PEEL assessment found the force needed to improve its approach to investigating crime and safeguarding vulnerable people. The force had previously been subject to enhanced monitoring, known as Engage, before that system was replaced by the new four-level performance framework.

The Police and Crime Commissioner is responsible for holding the force to account and setting policing priorities, while the Chief Constable retains operational independence.

Mr Vaughan was appointed Chief Constable in December 2024 and, earlier this month, his contract was extended for a further two years. The Commissioner said at the time that she remained confident in his experience, commitment and leadership as the force continued its improvement programme.

HMICFRS will now monitor the force's response to the latest recommendations, with inspectors calling for immediate action to improve the management of demand, allocation and supervision of investigations, and the identification and management of risk to victims.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice