Controversial bid for travellers’ site approved – but only for one family

The site at Charles, where caravans had been placed and which was given planning permission in May, now overturned by the High Court. placeholder image
The site at Charles, where caravans had been placed and which was given planning permission in May, now overturned by the High Court. | NDC

An application for travellers’ pitches at Charles near Brayford has been approved by North Devon Council, but only for the use of one family

A family has been allowed to stay in their caravans in an isolated location in North Devon but the area will cease as a travellers’ site once they leave.

North Devon Council’s planning committee voted by eight votes to four to approve two traveller pitches in a field at Charles, near Barnstaple.

Devon County Highways had opposed the part retrospective plan along with nearly 40 residents and Brayford Parish Council.

They raised concerns about the increase of traffic on the narrow approach roads and lack of footpaths. Issues of lighting in the open countryside and impact on the nearby Exmoor National Park were also highlighted.

Planning officers recommended the application for approval but said it was “finely balanced.” The council is under pressure to find more travellers sites because of a shortage in the district – it currently has eight, but needs to find another seven.

Committee members agreed this was not the most appropriate site but said it met the needs of the extended family living there who had a number of complex health conditions and could attend local health facilities.

Speaking on behalf of the applicant Philip Doran, who runs a roofing business and his wife Kathleen, Emily Temple said the scheme had been reduced from four to two pitches and was “a small single family development” and she claimed in five years there had been no collisions on the rural approach roads.

“Fundamentally there are no other sites available,” she said, adding it was not within a designated landscape or conservation area and new planting had been proposed to mitigate its effect.

The scheme includes space for two static caravans to live in and two touring caravans to travel in.

County councillor for South Molton, Councillor Richard Hopley, along with some residents who spoke at the meeting, said work had started on site which was “illegal and continued despite the applicant being asked to stop.”

The councillor said approving the application would set a precedent through North Devon that it was okay not to adhere to the rules.

Brian Symons, representing Brayford Parish Council, said there had been no change of use application to turn a greenfield into a brownfield site, but this had been done regardless.

He said the footprint of the site was the same for two pitches as it was for four and the size of the units had increased to fill it.

Cllr Liz Bulled for North Molton said there had been “inflammatory” reports in the press about this being a transit site where travellers just stopped rather than lived, but she said this was untrue.

She added: “It is for a settlement site for a small family unit so they can have access to education and more regular healthcare.”

She said that any application of any sort would be a minor inconvenience to some, but to others it could be life changing and urged members to concentrate on the policies rather than the number of objections.

Cllr Caroline Leaver asked that a condition be included to limit the application to the family and this was supported by officers and members, following a similar case study recently.

Cllr Leaver said: “This is not appropriate as a traveller site but at the same time this family has real and current need.”

The site will be returned to its former condition when the family leave and planning consent would need to be sought from future residents who wished to have a traveller pitch there.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice