Devon council pledges to clarify responsibility for monitoring quarry dust


Devon County Council is to establish which statutory body is responsible for monitoring respirable crystalline silica (RCS) outside mineral extraction sites, following concerns from residents living near quarries.
The move follows questions from campaigners which revealed that no statutory organisation currently has explicit responsibility for routinely monitoring RCS – a component of some mineral dusts which can pose a health risk when people are exposed to high levels over a prolonged period.
Devon County Council is responsible for determining planning applications for mineral extraction and can impose conditions requiring quarry operators to undertake dust monitoring. Residents who believe dust from quarries is affecting their health can also raise concerns with environmental health teams at their local district council.
However, a motion brought forward by Councillor Ed Hill (Independent, Pinhoe & Mincinglake) called for Devon to establish clearly which statutory body is responsible for protecting residents outside extraction sites from long-term exposure to RCS.
Cllr Hill said the issue was ultimately about ensuring there was independent accountability for monitoring potential exposure.
“I don’t trust the council to mark its own homework any more,” Cllr Hill said.
“We were being asked to accept that the existing regulatory framework adequately addresses the risk, yet [the council] has just confirmed that DCC holds no monitoring results specifically for RCS and that there is not a statutory body routinely monitoring it.”
The debate in Devon follows concerns about dust monitoring at the Denistone and Broadway Ball Clay sites. Monitoring is understood to take place at the sites, but measurements focus on the quantity of airborne dust rather than its specific composition. Cllr Hill said the distinction was central to his concerns.
“I am not claiming that residents are being exposed to dangerous levels of RCS,” he said.
“Nobody should make that claim without the evidence; my concern is almost the opposite – where is the evidence that allows us to confidently rule it out?”
Separately, information obtained by Martin Wrigley MP (Liberal Democrat, Newton Abbot) showed that monitoring had been carried out at two locations at the Denistone and Broadway Ball clay site – one adjacent to Preston village and another near Exeter Road.
Mr Wrigley said monitoring data he had seen “does not indicate dangerous levels of airborne particles and reports no risk to human health”, but acknowledged that the monitoring did not identify the composition of the dust.
He said Sibelco, which operates the quarries, had told him it had strengthened its dust-control measures. These included increased use of water bowsers to suppress dust and more intensive road sweeping.
The company had also committed to “improving communication with local residents through the publication of regular information and fact sheets”, according to the MP.
Concerns were also raised at the full council meeting by Holland Risley, a member of the Save Our Trees campaign group, about the impact of quarry traffic and dust on people living near the Zitherixon quarry at Rackerhayes, Kingsteignton.
“My children cycle along Exeter Road to football and the swimming pool, and when the road is dry, passing lorries lift dust in a cloud, and there are other residents that live just metres away,” he said.
Mr Risley said planning permission for the quarry required annual dust reporting, but claimed the council had told him that no reports had been submitted.
“Even the monitoring that does take place is built so it cannot see the problem,” he said.
“The operator has proposed monitoring by visual observation, but RCS is too fine to see.”
He also stated that ball clay consists of 30 per cent quartz and that silica was a group one carcinogen, while claiming Devon had confirmed to him that “no quarry in Devon monitors it”.
Another resident, Kelly Pearce, asked whether a statutory body could independently monitor RCS at her home.
In a written response, Councillor Caroline Leaver (Liberal Democrat, Barnstaple South) said there was “not a statutory body that routinely monitors RCS”.
“Dust is considered by Devon County Council in the assessment of planning applications for mineral working,” Cllr Leaver added.
“Silica can be found along with other dusts, and as such it can be controlled through conditions in any planning permission for dust monitoring.
“Where required, monitoring would consider PM10 (any airborne particle with an aerodynamic diameter of 10 microns (µm) or less), which includes RCS, rather than directly monitoring RCS.
“This approach is consistent with standard practice for assessing and managing dust impacts from mineral operations.”
The council's decision is intended to clarify the responsibilities of public bodies in relation to RCS monitoring and address concerns about whether existing arrangements provide sufficient oversight of potential exposure.
Sibelco, which operates the Zitherixon quarry, did not respond to a request for comment.