Environment Agency grants permit for controversial landfill site

The Environment Agency has granted an environmental permit to GRS Stone Supplies Ltd for a proposed inert landfill site at Lower Hare Farm in Whitestone, Exeter, following an extensive public consultation process. The decision, announced on Thursday, 3 April, comes after a detailed review of community feedback and technical assessments.

The Environment Agency’s decision was made in accordance with the Environmental Permitting Regulations (2016), which require permits to be issued if applicants meet all legal and environmental standards. The permit outlines strict conditions for managing and operating the landfill site, including controls on emissions to air, water, and land.

Chris James of the Environment Agency said that the decision-making process was rigorous in nature, stating: “We have carefully considered all of the submissions and feedback we received during our public consultations, and we thank everyone who took the time to contact us with their views. This permit will ensure that robust levels of environmental protection are applied. Our permitting decision process is objective and based on the applicant demonstrating they will meet the legal requirements outlined in the permit.”

The Environment Agency’s assessment considered the design of the site, operational procedures, and potential environmental impacts. The review process also involved input from partner organisations including the UK Health Security Agency.

The decision to approve the landfill site has been controversial, drawing criticism from local residents and environmental groups concerned about the impact on air quality, traffic, and rural landscapes. However, the Environment Agency clarified that issues such as site location, operating hours, and traffic management fall under the jurisdiction of the local planning authority, not the environmental permit. The Agency’s role is strictly limited to assessing technical and environmental criteria.

The Environment Agency can only refuse a permit if the applicant fails to meet technical requirements. With GRS Stone Supplies Ltd satisfying all necessary conditions, the permit was granted.

The permit requires GRS Stone Supplies Ltd to adhere to stringent environmental standards, including emission monitoring and control measures. Any breaches could result in enforcement action.

The Environment Agency will oversee compliance and regularly review the site’s environmental performance. The final permit, decision document, and related consultation materials are available on the public register. These can be requested via the Environment Agency’s Customer Contact Centre at 03706 506 506 or by emailing DCISEnquiries@environment-agency.gov.uk.

The Environmental Permitting Regulations (2016) were introduced to streamline and strengthen environmental protection by regulating activities that could impact the environment. The system aims to ensure that industries operate in an environmentally responsible manner.

The decision to permit the Lower Hare Farm landfill site is a good example of the complexities of balancing environmental protection, waste management, and community concerns. As the project moves forward, local residents and environmental advocates will undoubtedly continue to scrutinise its impact.