Dartmoor farmer warns of ‘shambolic’ funding system after SFI closure


A Dartmoor farming leader has described the current SFI funding system as “not fit for purpose” after it closed within hours, while Geoffrey Cox takes concerns to the Farming Minister
Dartmoor farmers need a farming support system designed around the realities of working on the moor, rather than national schemes that do not fit its unique landscape, a local farming leader has said.
The call came after the fourth annual Dartmoor Forum last Monday (September 21), chaired by Sir Geoffrey Cox KC MP, brought Farming Minister Stephen Morgan MP to a local upland farm to see first-hand the challenges facing farmers.
Dartmoor farming relies on shared common land, particular grazing arrangements and careful management of its vegetation and landscape. Farmers say these circumstances make it difficult to fit the moor into standard national funding schemes.
The forum followed David Fursdon’s Independent Review into the future of farming on Dartmoor and brought together farmers, statutory bodies and other organisations involved in managing the moor.
Mr Morgan visited a local farm before taking part in a panel discussion with NFU vice president Robyn Munt, Phil Stocker of the Dartmoor Land Use Management Group (DLUMG), Natural England’s David Slater and farmers.
Discussions focused on grazing, the economic viability of upland farming and how Dartmoor’s landscape can be managed while allowing farms to remain viable.


Sir Geoffrey said there was a need to make progress on the Fursdon Review and develop “flexible working methods and grazing arrangements” for farmers.
But the issue became more pressing days later when the latest Sustainable Farming Incentive (SFI) application window closed after £233 million of funding was taken up in just six hours.
Mat Cole, chair of the NFU South Uplands Group, told The Moorlander that the experience highlighted the difficulties farmers are facing.
Mr Cole said he had been preparing an application worth around £50,000 but was unable to submit it before the window closed.
He said he had been working on the application and was ready to put it through the online portal, but missed the deadline by around five minutes.
Mr Cole said the short window had made it “extremely difficult for farmers to plan” and added that he did not know whether there would be another opportunity to apply.
Mr Cole described the Government’s approach as “a shambolic way to run a government agreement” and argued that farmers needed proper funding for the environmental work they were already carrying out.
-Uplands-South-Group.jpeg?crop=3:2,smart&trim=&width=640&quality=65)

He said Dartmoor farmers “want to graze and manage the land properly”, including its vegetation, while continuing to deliver environmental benefits.
“It illustrates how far off the mark the Government is,” he said of the different levels of farming support currently being developed.
The SFI is intended to provide a broad base level of environmental support, while higher-level schemes are designed for more involved environmental work and landscape recovery.
Mr Cole said the current arrangements were “not fit for purpose” for Dartmoor and that the moor requires a more tailored approach.
He said the visit by the Farming Minister had been a positive opportunity to explain Dartmoor’s circumstances and put the case for farmers directly to the Government.
“We’re delivering for the environment in spades,” he said. “All we ask is that the Government fund it properly.”


The forum also considered work by the DLUMG, including landscape trials which could help shape bespoke agri-environment schemes for Dartmoor.
Sir Geoffrey said farmers needed clarity during a period of transition, particularly as existing Higher Level Stewardship (HLS) agreements come to an end and there remains uncertainty around future agri-environment funding.
He said the Minister’s willingness to listen and take the concerns back to Whitehall was welcome, particularly his engagement with developing “bespoke and flexible arrangements” for Dartmoor.
In the days since the forum, Sir Geoffrey committed to writing to Mr Morgan about the concerns raised by farmers following the SFI closure.
He said action on the recommendations of the Fursdon Review “must be accelerated”, with farming support balancing the economic viability of farms with the protection of Dartmoor’s landscape.
For Mr Cole, the immediate issue lies in forward planning.
He said farmers needed to know what support would be available and how they could continue managing land which has been subject to environmental agreements for many years.